Secular States, Religious Politics: India, Turkey, and the Future of Secularism
- This event has passed.
Secular States, Religious Politics: India, Turkey, and the Future of Secularism
22nd November 2018 @ 6:30 pm - 7:30 pm
India and Turkey were the two exemplars of twentieth-century ‘secular states’ outside of the West. Professor Sumantra Bose believes that in the early 21st century Hanafi-Sunni Islamists have decisively taken over the state in Turkey, and in India Hindu nationalists have emerged as by far the leading political force. What explains the collapse, in all but name, of the secular state in Turkey, and its decline in India? Will Turkey’s anti-secular political transformation be replicated in India?
Sumantra Bose draws on his new book, Secular States, Religious Politics: India, Turkey, and the Future of Secularism (Cambridge University Press, 2018) to discuss the current course of events in the two pivotal countries.
The Henry Jackson Society is pleased to invite you to join Professor Sumantra Bose about Turkey and India and the rise of religious-nationalist politics in the two historically secular states, and decline of secularism as a salient common feature of the politics of both countries. Signed copies of the book will be available after the event.
Professor Sumantra Bose – is Professor of International and Comparative Politics at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE). Hs many books include Transforming India: Challenges to the World’s Largest Democracy (Harvard, 2013), Contested Lands: Israel-Palestine, Kashmir, Bosnia, Cyprus, and Sri Lanka (Harvard, 2007), Kashmir: Roots of Conflict, Paths to Peace (Harvard, 2003), and Bosnia after Dayton: Nationalist Partition and International Intervention (Oxford, 2002). Bose graduated from Amherst College in Massachusetts in 1992 and received his PhD from Columbia University, New York, in 1998.
Dr John Hemmings – is Director of Asia Studies Centre at the Henry Jackson Society and an Adjunct Fellow at the Centre for Strategic and International Studies. Prior to his doctoral studies, he was a visiting fellow at Pacific Forum CSIS and a research analyst at the Royal United Services Institute in Whitehall, working on Northeast Asia security and defence policies. He has written on foreign and security policy in Northeast Asia for nearly 10 years and had research positions at the Royal United Services Institute and the Asia Foundation. He contributes political analysis to various media, including the BBC, the Telegraph, Fox News, CNN, the Mainichi Shimbun, the Diplomat, and the National Interest; and is a regular on Monocle 24 Radio.
The Henry Jackson Society hosted this discussion on the subject of the decline and erosion of secularism in India and Turkey, respectively. Prof Sumantra Bose, who is a Professor of International and Comparative Politics at the London School of Economics was the key speaker, and Jamila Mammadova was its chair.
His discussion centred around trying to identify reasons for the complete dismantling of the Kemalist secular state in Turkey, and the rise of Hindu nationalism in India. The event started with Prof Bose outlining a working definition of secularism for the sake of the discussion. He commented that secularism in these two countries has the particular characteristic of impartiality, that the state is impartial to all faiths, but is nevertheless excessively embroiled in matters of faith. The second point of excessive involvement differentiates secularism in these countries from models in the west,
and is what makes ‘impartiality’ a tall order. He argued that secularism took shape in Turkey with the Kemalists imposing a very Eurocentric understanding of the concept- authoritatively on the people. On the other hand, secularism in India was democratically imposed, had its roots in Indian tradition of co-existence – and was only the practical necessity for ensuring the unity of a highly diverse country.
He said that the Turkish Kemalist state, by calling for ruptures with tradition and viewing Islam as backward and outlawing the exhibition of religiosity, let the genie of backlash out of the bottle, paving way ultimately for Erdogan’s popularity. The Indian state while upholding the concept of secularism and impartiality imbibed a deeply ingrained bias towards the majority faith of Hinduism, with the state giving in to the demands of Hindu groups, ultimately modelling itself as a ‘soft’ Hindu state. He then spoke of the rise of Hanafi Sunnis in Turkey in 1980s and 90s, and the parallel rise of Hindu nationalists in India around that time. He argued that supposedly secular leaders who gave in to the demands of religious orthodoxy in both countries ultimately lead to their rise. He commented that in the 1980s, the Indian National Congress’s leaders made compromises with Hindutva majoritarianism as part of their broader electoral strategy, leading to the rise of this ideology from the margins to the position it is in today wherein the party that closely represents it, the BJP has a majority in the Lok Sabha, and has formed governments- on its own, or with partners- in majority of Indian states.
The discussion was followed by a Q&A session wherein a range of questions were asked covering topics including the Sikh Pogrom of 1984 under ‘secular’ Indian National Congress, EU’s fault with regard to de-secularisation of Turkey, Erdogan and Modi’s personalities, Ataturk’s significance in Erdogan’s Turkey, diasporas and their connect to home-countries, effect of modern education etc.
According to Elif Shafak, culture and literature matters. It becomes especially relevant in the age of populism, pessimism and political … Continued
The unfolding crisis in Venezuela represents a major challenge not only for the country’s citizens, but also for the international community. … Continued
As we commemorate the 30th anniversary of the events culminating in the Tiananmen Square Massacre of June 4th 1989, it is important to note … Continued
As the strategic environment changes, planning for state-on-state military confrontation has re-emerged. Non-state actors – perhaps assisted by revisionist powers … Continued
The BJP had an impressive victory in the 2019 General Election, emerging as the single largest party garnering more vote … Continued
In the twenty-five years after 1989, the world enjoyed the deepest peace in history. In The Rise and Fall of … Continued
In recent times, national populism has been on the march in much of the Western world. 2016 was a year … Continued
Twenty years after NATO’s bombing of Yugoslavia, the Western Balkans countries are beset by economic, political, and social uncertainty. The … Continued
In light of the publication of the Modernising Defence Programme in December 2018, which recognised the emergence of a more … Continued
The relationship between Russia and the West is once again deep in crisis. A major reason for this is that … Continued
The special relationship is under strain. President Donald Trump’s unorthodox approach to foreign policy together and the uncertainty caused by … Continued
On March 29, the United Nations adopted Security Council Resolution 2367 on sexual violence in conflict. Questions have been raised, … Continued
In late 2013, the People’s Republic of China began building and fortifying islands across a number of reefs in the … Continued
The Wealth Effect: How the Great Expectations of the Middle Class Have Changed the Politics of Banking Crises
The rising wealth of middle class households and voters has transformed the politics of banking crises. At this event, Jeffrey … Continued
In the state elections in December 2018, the big loser was the BJP, which had won 62 of 65 Lok … Continued
Belarus has received increased international attention over recent years, much of which has focused on Russia’s ambitions towards the country. … Continued
With returning IS fighters and uncertainty over Brexit, concerns surrounding human rights, civil liberties and national security have never been … Continued
Putin’s Hostages: Ukrainian Political Prisoners of the Kremlin is a documentary about the roughly 70 Ukrainians political prisoners incarcerated … Continued
In the eyes of many, the prospect of a two-state solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict is diminishing. With peace talks … Continued
Hon. Malcolm Turnbull, Australia’s 29th Prime Minister, on ‘Preserving the Freedom of the Asia Pacific’
The Henry Jackson Society is delighted to host Hon. Malcolm Turnbull, Former Australian Prime Minister, for a special event chaired … Continued
Five years ago next month, Russia annexed Crimea in the first forcible annexation of the territory of a European country … Continued
Western liberalism is under attack, not only at home also but from newly-emboldened authoritarian states abroad. Across the West, states … Continued
Deep new rifts are tearing apart the fabric of Britain and other Western societies: thriving cities versus the provinces, the … Continued
Though mankind has traded tangible goods for millennia, recent technology has changed the fundamentals of trade, in both legitimate and … Continued
China’s Belt and Road strategy is acknowledged to be the most ambitious geopolitical initiative of the age. Covering almost seventy countries by land … Continued
Why Middle Eastern Jewish Refugees Are Key to Understanding and Resolving the Israel-Palestine Conflict
Jews lived continuously in the Middle East and North Africa for almost 3,000 years. But in just 50 years, indigenous communities … Continued
India and Turkey were the two exemplars of twentieth-century ‘secular states’ outside of the West. Professor Sumantra Bose believes that … Continued
The political events of recent years have sent shockwaves throughout the established order of Western liberal democracies. Election after election … Continued
Prof. Andrew Lambert’s new book, Seapower States examines how Britain and four other seapowers used their special identities to inform … Continued
Dave Rich’s updated edition of The Left’s Jewish Problem: Jeremy Corbyn, Israel and Antisemitism (2018) contends that antisemitism is a … Continued
Moneyland is the secret country of the wealthy and unscrupulous, the place where they put their assets, their children and … Continued
The Afghanistan War has now lasted for 17 years, and estimates suggest has cost the US government upwards of $750 … Continued
The Middle East remains one of the most tumultuous regions in the world today, with its many ethnic and religious … Continued
The past 18 months have seen an immense amount of economic, diplomatic, and even military activity relating to the Korean … Continued
As one of al-Qaeda's most respected bomb-makers, Aimen Dean rubbed shoulders with the mastermind of the 9/11 attacks and swore … Continued
The most dangerous threat we face today is no longer military, but rather the increasingly pervasive exposure of our personal … Continued
SPEAKER: Professor Carl Minzner, author, End of an Era China’s reform era is ending. Core factors that characterised its political stability, … Continued
SPEAKERS: His Excellency Renato Carlos Sersale di Cerisano - The Argentine Ambassador to the United Kingdom; Dr. Shimon Samuels - … Continued
SPEAKERS: Dr Michael Green - Author of By More Than Providence and Senior Vice President for Asia and Japan Chair … Continued
In the midst of some great changes in the international system, countries have been left with the qaundry of how … Continued
SPEAKER: Eliot Higgins, Founder of Bellingcat The destruction of Malaysian Airlines Flight MH17 over eastern Ukraine in July 2014 shocked the … Continued
SPEAKERS: Humphrey Hawksley, author of Asian Waters: The Struggle Over the Asia-Pacific and the Strategy of Chinese Expansion ; Bill Hayton, Associate Fellow … Continued
PROFESSOR NIGEL BIGGAR, Regius Professor of Moral and Pastoral Theology, Oxford University, in conversation with Douglas Murray The nation-state is … Continued
SPEAKER: EHUD OLMERT, former Prime Minister of Israel It’s been 10 years since the last meaningful peace deal was put … Continued
Whatever one’s feelings toward the outcome of the 2016 US elections, there can be no doubting the historic impact and … Continued
As Britain considers its relationship with Europe, European security has never been more precarious, with Russian revanchism on the rise … Continued
As the United Kingdom leaves the European Union, geopolitics is returning to the European continent. Germany and France are squabbling … Continued