Romanian politicians are engaged in political score-settling and serious violations of human rights which are dressed up as anti-corruption efforts, a new report from The Henry Jackson Society has found. The report, Fighting Corruption with Con Tricks: Romania’s Assault on the Rule of Law, warns practices that show considerable continuity with the communist era are taking place. The National Anti-corruption Directorate (DNA), for example, is an active participant in political struggles, and there is a strong correlation between those targeted for prosecution and the interests of those in power. Politicians are able to exert influence over the DNA using their control of key appointments, and by directing high-profile investigations. There is growing concern that the intelligence services are also involved, and with the DNA they are believed to be undermining judicial independence. All of this has the effect of weakening of the rule of law.
The report’s key findings include:
- There are concerns that the intelligence services are covertly directing anti-corruption prosecutions. However, the government has refused to investigate allegations that the intelligence services have infiltrated the judiciary and prosecution services.
- There have been numerous abuses of process. Arrested individuals have been paraded before the media in handcuffs, relatives of suspects have been threatened with indictment, suspects have been offered immunity for implicating someone more newsworthy, and evidence has been systematically leaked to the media.
- Crucial principles of justice enshrined in the European Convention on Human Rights, as well as the European Union’s Charter of Fundamental Rights, are being routinely violated. This includes the right to a fair trial and the presumption of innocence.
Romania’s international partners should consider these as matters of serious concern, and should act. The report recommends a range of measures through existing mechanisms on the part of the UK, the EU, and the US State Department. In particular, the European Commission should trigger its Rule of Law Mechanism, which is designed to deal with emerging systemic threats to the rule of law within the EU. Additionally, the UK should either reform or replace the European Arrest Warrant (EAW) to include stronger human rights safeguards; there have been two recent cases where the Romanian authorities were able to use the EAW to pursue politically motivated legal actions through UK courts.
David Clark, the report author, said;
“Europe’s leaders have been exceptionally naïve in accepting Romania’s claim to be cracking down on corruption, Romania’s anti-corruption drive has itself become a tool of political corruption.
There is considerable evidence that investigations are used to settle political scores, that prosecutors collude with government, that judges are improperly influenced to maintain high conviction rates, that the domestic intelligence service plays a covert role in manipulating the criminal justice system and that abuses of due process are routine.
The result is that basic standards of human rights are being regularly infringed, including the right to a fair trial and the right to a presumption of innocence.
The EU’s complacency about Romania creates the very real risk of creeping authoritarianism as other countries realise that anti-corruption campaigns provide convenient cover for bypassing the democratic standards that are supposed to bind together all European countries.”
Notes to Editors:
The Henry Jackson Society is a think tank and policy-shaping force that fights for the principles and alliances which keep societies free – working across borders and party lines to combat extremism, advance democracy and real human rights, and make a stand in an increasingly uncertain world. Henry Jackson Society research and events provide key analysis and insight to policy-makers and the media.
Related past research from The Henry Jackson Society includes:
- The State of Democracy After 25 Years: Lessons from Central and Eastern Europe, January 2015
- Russia’s Role in the Balkans – Cause for Concern?, June 2014
The Henry Jackson Society can provide interviews with analysts including the report author, David Clark
For interview requests, please contact The Henry Jackson Society.
+44 (0)20 7340 4520