HJS Blog - The Scoop

Scraping the Barrel

posted by Jonathan Rider at 24/06/2009

The BBC has recently uncovered yet more allegations of abuse and mistreatment of prisoners by US troops in Bagram airbase. I have written about a similar issue in the past, and I want to reiterate again, that I do not condone any form of abuse or torture under any circumstances. That said, I am tired of reading about alleged prisoner abuse at the hands of child-eating, sado-masochistic soldiers.

I am not in possession of all the facts. However, it strikes me that if you look hard enough, you will find what you are looking for. That’s not to say that diligence will be rewarded by discovery. I mean that if you spend enough time staring at the clouds you are bound to see the odd cumulonimbus that resembles, however tenuously, something else. I wonder if the same thing seems to be happening with some of these reports and surveys. If you ask enough people if they enjoyed their stay, a small number are bound to complain.

Just to be clear, it is important that detainees are treated with humanity and that their custodians are under constant scrutiny, but the relentless determination of some journalists to uncover brutal stories of torture and abuse is, I suspect, more about publicity and selling a good story than exposing a corrupt and illegal practices.

The latest survey found that some inmates suffered from sleep deprivation, extreme hot and cold, excessively loud noises and physical abuse. What was school if not one long exercise of sleep deprivation, stressful positions, physical abuse and loud noise? The allegations obviously warrant investigation, but they certainly don’t deserve the media attention.

 

 


Comments:

At 20/10/2009 01:56:30, richard merchant says:

-blasé [&#712bl&#593&#720ze&#618]

indifferent to something because of familiarity or surfeit
(oxford english dictionary)


-staggering [&#712stæg&#601r&#618&#331]
astounding or overwhelming shocking
(oxford english)

and since we're quoting dictionaries, heres one from America...


TORTURE, punishments. A punishment inflicted in some countries on supposed criminals to induce them to confess their crimes, and to reveal their associates.
2. This absurd and tyrannical practice never was in use in the United States for no man is bound to accuse himself. An attempt to torture a person accused of crime, in order to extort a confession, is an indictable offence. 2 Tyler, 380. Vide Question.

A Law Dictionary, Adapted to the Constitution and Laws of the United States. By John Bouvier. Published 1856.

At 29/06/2009 15:41:38, Alan Ayling says:

Wonderful, I agree. It would be nice to have a bit more grown-up realism about the whole theatre war.

Post a comment

  • captcha refresh

Please note that the content of these blogs do not necessarily represent the views of The Henry Jackson Society. The Henry Jackson Society is also not responsible for the content of external internet sites.