Support the
Henry Jackson

Our work is only possible through the generosity of private philanthropy. Find out how you can support our mission and can contribute to our work.

Members' log in
The Scoop
September 26, 2012

How useful is aid in Yemen?

Robin Simcox

President Hadi recently departed Yemen to undertake a foreign tour, meeting key allies and Western leaders. President Obama and Prime Minister Cameron both recently met Hadi, as did the Jordanian King.

Top of the list of any discussion between the U.S. and Yemen is counter-terrorism. Yet there is an increasing acceptance that this must go hand in hand with a concerted attempt to build up the Yemeni government, improve Yemeni infrastructure and invest in civil society initiatives. Drones alone will not fix the al-Qaeda problem. However, as I argued last year, pouring in aid is of little use if the government is unable to distribute it efficiently (an argument which holds across the aid spectrum, not just in Yemen).

This argument was considered this week by Abubakr al-Shamahi, a British Yemeni journalist, in the Guardian. The piece is worth reading in full, yet seems to come to the same uneasy conclusion as many policy makers: that while keeping on pumping millions of dollars in aid into Yemen is ineffective, nobody is coming up with a better alternative.

It seems patently clear that just throwing huge amounts of Western money at the problem is not the solution – just look at the problems that remain in Africa. However, making the argument that such countries will improve with less U.S. economic assistance but more U.S. drones and missiles is also clearly problematic, to say the least. There remains a significant amount of further fresh thinking to be done by the academic and policy community as to how governments can reconcile these two positions.

Robin Simcox

About Robin Simcox

Robin Simcox is a Research Fellow at the Henry Jackson Society, where he specialises in al-Qaeda and al-Qaeda inspired terrorism. He is the co-author of both editions of 'Islamist Terrorism: The British Connections' and several other reports broadly focussed on national security, terrorism and al-Qaeda and al-Qaeda affiliated movements across the world. Simcox has written for the likes of the Wall Street Journal, New Republic, Guardian, Weekly Standard, Spectator, Huffington Post and Daily Telegraph and regularly appears across a broad variety of media outlets, including the BBC, Fox News, Sky News, Channel 4 and al-Jazeera. He has spoken on a variety of platforms, including the British Parliament, US Special Operations Command and the European Parliament.

Full profile  |  See all of Robin Simcox's work