Support the
Henry Jackson
Society

Our work is only possible through the generosity of private philanthropy. Find out how you can support our mission and can contribute to our work.

Members' log in
The Scoop
January 19, 2012

Someone Give Cristina Kirchner a Copy of the UN Charter

by
George Grant

As the 30th Anniversary of the 1982 conflict between Britain and Argentina approaches, the Falklands dispute is yet again making waves.

There has been little respite in the increasingly bellicose huffing and puffing emitting from Buenos Aires in recent months, levelling accusations of colonialism at Britain on account of its retention of ‘Las Malvinas’, over which Argentina itself claims sovereignty.

Tensions began rising in February 2010, when a British company commenced drilling for oil in the Falkland Islands’ territorial waters. Argentina responded by threatening to take “adequate measures” against this egregious assertion of sovereign rights, and declared its intention to impose restrictions on shipping in the area.

In November of last year, this rhetoric was matched with aggressive action, when the Argentine navy boarded a Spanish fishing vessel that it accused of operating “illegally” in the South Atlantic. The following month, they went one further, clubbing together with Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay to close their ports to any vessel flying the Falklands flag. The fact that one of these countries, Paraguay, is landlocked did not seem to bother this Latin American quartet too much.

In response to these actions, David Cameron yesterday approved contingency plans for a rapid increase in Britain’s military presence in the Falklands, reasserting once again that the islands’ sovereignty is not up for negotiation.

He also turned Buenos Aires’s traditional protestations on their head and asserted that it is not Britain, but Argentina, that is guilty of colonialism. And he is absolutely right.

Anyone wishing to determine which country can rightfully claim sovereignty need look no further than the Article 1.2 of the Charter of the United Nations which explicitly upholds “the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples”. This is a clear rejection of imperialistic notions that the government of one nation has the right to claim sovereignty over the peoples of another state or territory against the latter’s will.

Under those conditions, who then is the imperialist, Argentina or the United Kingdom? The answer could not be clearer: Argentina is the imperialist. The desire of the Falkland Islanders themselves to remain British is almost universal.

The question of geographical proximity is irrelevant. It is a modification of the ‘saltwater fallacy’ employed by the Soviet Union during the Cold War to criticise the imperialism of Britain and France, whilst maintaining its own empire in Eastern Europe. If geographical proximity was what mattered, then Alaska should be a part of Canada and not the United States. Ridiculous, no?

No more ridiculous than Argentina’s completely baseless claims to sovereignty over the Falkland Islands. As and when the Falkland Islanders express their wish to become Argentine (a wish, incidentally, which recedes ever further into the distance with each act of Argentine aggression) then there will be something to debate. In the meantime, can somebody please hand Christina Kirchner a copy of the UN Charter?

George Grant

About George Grant

George Grant was a non-resident Associate Fellow at The Henry Jackson Society. Between 2009-2012 George was a full-time Research Fellow at HJS, before moving to Libya to become Deputy Editor of the Libya Herald, the first post-Gaddafi English-language daily, and Libya Correspondent for The Times. He returned to the UK at the start of 2013 owing to an abduction threat received following an investigation he was conducting into a death list in Benghazi. His most recent report, In Scotland's Defence? An Assessment of SNP Defence Strategy, provides a comprehensive analysis of the Scottish National Party's proposals for how they would defend an independent Scotland. A frequent contributor to mainstream newspapers and broadcasters, including the Daily Telegraph, the Guardian, Al Jazeera and the BBC, George has also given briefings and evidence to Parliamentary Select Committees, UK Government departments and the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst in the fields of foreign policy, strategy and defence. George holds Masters degrees in History from the University of Edinburgh and Investigative Journalism from City University, London. He is a keen squash player and runner, and an active member of his local Church in Wimbledon.

Full profile  |  See all of George Grant's work