Support the
Henry Jackson

Our work is only possible through the generosity of private philanthropy. Find out how you can support our mission and can contribute to our work.

Members' log in
The Scoop
July 5, 2011

Time to think again on food security

George Grant

Once again the rains have failed over the Horn of Africa; once again millions are faced with the bleak prospect of malnourishment or starvation; and once again the calls have gone out from the aid agencies for urgent international help. The story is as tragic as it is tragically familiar.

In Djibouti, Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia and Uganda, more than nine million people are reckoned to be ‘critically short of food’, many of them in regions of conflict that the aid agencies find difficult to access. Clearly, international assistance is urgently needed, and the pledge from our own International Development Secretary, Andrew Mitchell, to commit an extra £38 million in food is surely to be welcomed.

But underlying all of this, the question must be asked as to why it is that this region makes so little progress in overcoming the climactic difficulties with which it has been endowed. Adapting to, if not overcoming, the elements is after all a human speciality; just ask the Eskimos, or the Israelis for that matter, who successfully irrigate a country with less than half the annual rainfall of Ethiopia.

Clearly, the weakness (or in Somalia’s case, de facto non-existence) of national governments is a major part of the problem. Far too little is being done to reduce corruption, which remains chronically high across the region according to Transparency International and governance generally remains very poor.

It is a telling indicator, as Jonathan Clayton points out in today’s Times, that 135 tonnes of fresh flowers and vegetables leave Kenya for Britain every day, at a time when 3.5 million Kenyans are facing potential starvation. Entire books have been written on the problem of throwing aid at the symptoms of a problem, and doing little to redress its cause, but this is no less true for being said so often, and the British Government and others must work seriously to help address this issue.

The second problem, however, remains the region’s reluctance to adopt GM crops, ‘advised’ by largely Western pressure groups that they will only exacerbate the problem. Without question, the decision to introduce genetically modified produce into any habitat must be very carefully considered, and subjected to the most rigorous scrutiny. But over the past decade,according to former anti-GM campaigner Mark Lynas, there has not been “a single substantiated case of GM foods having had any negative effects on health or the environment anywhere in the world”. I certainly haven’t heard of any, and I have little doubt that all the relevant lobby groups would have wasted no time in making the dangers very public if such cases had been proven. GM crops can increase yields by several hundred per cent, as well as enabling the production of crops in arid or other inhospitable climates where non-GM crops are inclined to fail.

So let’s start to think again about food security in Africa, and put aside some of the old prejudices; millions of human lives could depend on it.

George Grant

About George Grant

George Grant was a non-resident Associate Fellow at The Henry Jackson Society. Between 2009-2012 George was a full-time Research Fellow at HJS, before moving to Libya to become Deputy Editor of the Libya Herald, the first post-Gaddafi English-language daily, and Libya Correspondent for The Times. He returned to the UK at the start of 2013 owing to an abduction threat received following an investigation he was conducting into a death list in Benghazi. His most recent report, In Scotland's Defence? An Assessment of SNP Defence Strategy, provides a comprehensive analysis of the Scottish National Party's proposals for how they would defend an independent Scotland. A frequent contributor to mainstream newspapers and broadcasters, including the Daily Telegraph, the Guardian, Al Jazeera and the BBC, George has also given briefings and evidence to Parliamentary Select Committees, UK Government departments and the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst in the fields of foreign policy, strategy and defence. George holds Masters degrees in History from the University of Edinburgh and Investigative Journalism from City University, London. He is a keen squash player and runner, and an active member of his local Church in Wimbledon.

Full profile  |  See all of George Grant's work